Two people stand at the rim of the Grand Canyon. One is overcome with awe at nature’s grandeur, while the other sees an enormous rift in the landscape. What accounts for the difference? This week, Jungian analyst and scholar John R. White joins hosts Lisa Marchiano and Deborah Stewart to explore Jung’s feeling function, our capacity to discern what matters.
What is Jungian Typology?
One of Jung’s best-known legacies is his categorization of ego functions: typology. Whether we are extraverted or introverted (terms Jung introduced), our four basic ego functions sort themselves into intuition, sensation, thinking, and feeling. We have all four functions but prefer some over others. Jung’s system led directly to the creation of the widely used Myers-Briggs Personality Type Indicator.
Explaining the Feeling Function
The feeling and thinking functions are both ways of making judgments, but the feeling function is based on personal values: if you were a military commander, would you be like Napoleon, directing his troops from the hilltop — or like Braveheart, leading his men on the field? When the feeling function is cultivated and differentiated, it illuminates much of how and why we do what we do. Do we tend to prefer a subjective stance based on personal values, or a more objective and strategic stance?
Why You Should Develop Your Feeling Function
Developing our feeling function may be challenging in the context of a culture that prioritizes thinking and sensate functions over feeling and intuition. It is a task worth taking on, however. Evaluating our experiences up close as well as from the greater distance the thinking function affords can be a profound step toward growth and individuation. Discerning whether the basis of a decision should be subjective or objective builds consciousness and expands choice. Since subjectivity is closely aligned with feelings, we can reflect on what a bruising encounter has made us feel—and choose our response rather than reacting.
We discuss some of the strategies you might use to differentiate your feeling function, including:
- Embarking on analysis,
- Writing in your journal,
- Eugene Gendlin’s focusing technique, which asks us to tune into the body and carefully name what is felt.
Why Your Inferior Function is Important
In many cases, the individual’s experience is that certain functions are overdeveloped, and their opposite is underdeveloped, which Jung described as the “inferior function”. If the feeling function is underdeveloped for you, cultivating and nurturing it is a key task of individuation – it may be where you find what’s in your shadow, as well as experience of the numinous.
Our Guest – John R. White, Ph.D
John R. White is a Jungian psychoanalyst and mental health counselor in private practice in Pittsburgh PA. He was Coordinator of the C. G. Jung Institute Analyst Training Program of Pittsburgh (2019-2026) and is President-elect of the Board of the Pittsburgh Psychoanalytic Center. Before becoming a psychotherapist and training analyst, he was a philosophy professor (primarily at Franciscan University of Steubenville OH) and is currently a Scholar-in-residence at the Simon Silverman Phenomenology Center, Duquesne University, in Pittsburgh. He is also an esoteric practitioner and a Hermetic initiate.
John’s recent publications include:
- (Book) Adaptation and Psychotherapy. Langs and Analytical Psychology. Rowman & Littlefield (2023).
- (Co-edited book) Jungian Analysis in the World on Fire. At the Nexus of Individual and Collective Trauma. Routledge (2024).
- (Book chapter) “Ressentiment: Its Phenomenology and Clinical Significance,” in Roger Brooke, ed., Jungian Psychology and the Human Sciences, Routledge 2024.
- (Book Chapter) “Colonizing the American psyche. Virtue and the problem of consumer capitalism,” In Critical Theory and Psychoanalysis. From the Frankfurt School to Contemporary Critique, edited by Daniel Burston and Jon Mills, New York, Routledge 2023, 211-230.
Here’s the Dream We Analyze
I’m following this woman who’s an outdoor guide on a hike that is both awe inspiring and seemingly treacherous. The trail is sort of cavernous, and otherworldly, covered in snow but with lava just beneath the surface, which is bubbling up and breaking through in places. I wonder how it’s possible these opposites even exist in the same place. This guide is friendly, experienced, capable and sort of masculine, and though it’s a bit frightening, I feel like I’m in good hands. Soon I realize that we’re not supposed to be doing this. At the end of the trail, it’s like we’re trying to make sure someone doesn’t find out that we were here. I leave with someone else who’s like an uber driver, a young guy who’s aware we’re trying to be stealthy and trying to make sure we aren’t followed. We stop at a house where I’ve left my things, and as I gather them, I’m thinking of a story I can tell my stepmother to explain where I’ve been. I don’t like lying, but I know I can’t tell her about the hike, so I’m trying to come up with something really simple so that I don’t have to sell the story too hard. Then I wake up.
Resources from the Episode
- Iain McGilchrist, The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World.
- John R. White, “Ressentiment: Its phenomenology and clinical significance”, Jungian Psychology and the Human Sciences, 2024.
- Learn more about Eugene T. Gendlin’s work on focusing here.
Related Episodes
If you’ve enjoyed this episode, we recommend these related conversations:
